Worth It Financial

Elementary · 4th grade · SS4E1

Money choices in U.S. history

Settlers, farmers, miners, and inventors all made choices about money and time, and six big ideas explain them.

The standard

What Georgia asks you to know

SS4E1: Use the basic economic concepts of trade, opportunity cost, specialization, voluntary exchange, productivity, and price incentives to illustrate historical events.

  • Describe opportunity cost and its relationship to decision-making across time (e.g., decisions to settle in the west).
  • Explain how price incentives affect people’s behavior and choices: decisions about what crops (e.g., cotton, and tobacco) to grow and products (e.g., textiles) to produce.
  • Describe how specialization improves standards of living (e.g., differences in the economies in the North and South).
  • Explain how voluntary exchange helps both buyers and sellers (e.g., Gold Rush mining towns).
  • Describe how trade promotes economic activity (e.g., trade between the U.S. and Europe).
  • Give examples of technological advancements and their impact on business productivity during the development of the United States (e.g., cotton gin, steamboat, steam locomotive, and telegraph).

Everything below covers all six, then keeps going into what the standard leaves out.

In real life

One wagon, 2,000 miles

Families once left Independence, Missouri, for Oregon in covered wagons. The trip was about 2,000 miles and took 4 to 6 months, at 12 to 15 miles a day [1].

Every family faced an opportunity cost. That is the best thing you give up when you choose something else. Going west meant giving up a home, friends, and family back East. Staying meant giving up the chance at new land. In 1862, the Homestead Act offered 160 acres to a settler who lived on the land and farmed it for five years [2].

The wagon forced choices too. It could carry about 2,500 pounds. One 1849 guidebook listed the food three people needed for the trip. The foods on that list with weights add up to 2,170 pounds, and it named more foods besides. Even the weighed foods left only 330 pounds for everything else [1]. Families left favorite furniture behind to make room for plows, seeds, and tools [1].

Try it

Pack the wagon

The weighed foods come from that 1849 guidebook [1]. The other weights are examples. Everything you leave out is part of your opportunity cost.

Weighed food for three people

Everything else (example weights)

330 lb
room left in the wagon
Packed2,170 lb
Wagon limit2,500 lb
Left behindplow and tools, bedding and clothes, seeds to plant, rocking chair, box of books

The extras add up to 370 pounds, more than the 330 pounds of room. You cannot take everything, so something has to stay behind.

Fun sheet

Trail Through History, a board game

Color the board, make a paper clip spinner, and race from Jamestown to the railroad of 1869. Each event square shows one of the six ideas. The rules are on the sheet, plus a page for grown-ups.

Five more ideas

The other money ideas in history

Price incentives: grow what sells

A price incentive is a high price that pulls people to make more of something. At Jamestown, Virginia, colonists saw how valuable tobacco was. Spanish tobacco was said to be “worth its weight in silver,” and English buyers wanted more. In 1615 to 1616 the colony sent England 2,300 pounds of it. By 1640 London was getting nearly 1.5 million pounds a year, and a 1617 report said the colonists were “dispersed about, planting tobacco” [3]. Cotton later pulled Southern farmers the same way. In the North, mill owners made textiles, or cloth. Lowell, Massachusetts, opened its first mill in 1823 [4].

Specialization: the North and the South

Specialization means making a few things and trading for the rest. By 1850 the United States, almost all of it in the South, grew three-quarters of the world’s cotton. In the 1850s the North had 72% of the country’s factories and machines for making goods [5]. Specializing lets people make more, which can raise the standard of living, meaning how well people live. It did not raise it for everyone (see Beyond the standard).

Voluntary exchange: pies in a mining town

After gold was found in California in 1848, about 300,000 people moved there [6]. One baker sold fruit pies for $1.25 each. Merchants charged $2.50 to carry a letter and $1.50 for a newspaper that cost a nickel back East [6]. Voluntary exchange is a trade both sides choose freely. A hungry miner wanted the pie more than his $1.25. The baker wanted the $1.25 more than the pie. Both came out ahead.

Trade: cotton across the ocean

Trade is buying and selling. Before the Civil War, cotton was America’s top export. In 1860, the South sent 3 million bales to Europe, and 77% of the cotton used in Great Britain came from the American South [7].

Productivity: inventions do more with less

Productivity is how much work gets done in a set amount of time. New machines raised it fast.

  • Eli Whitney got a patent for his cotton gin. He wrote that one man and a horse could do more than fifty men with the old machines [5].
  • Robert Fulton’s steamboat went 150 miles up the Hudson River, from New York to Albany, in about 32 hours. It moved 4 to 5 miles an hour against the current [8].
  • The Pony Express carried mail more than 1,800 miles in 10 days. On October 26, 1861, the telegraph linked San Francisco and New York, and the Pony Express ended [9].
You decide: which idea is it?

A farmer hears cotton prices went up and plants more cotton. Price incentive.

A shop owner can send an order by telegraph instead of waiting 10 days for mail. Productivity.

A family leaves the rocking chair to make room for seeds. Opportunity cost: the chair is what they gave up.

Beyond the standard

What the textbook version leaves out

Not every exchange was voluntary

Southern cotton was grown by enslaved people, who were forced to work and were not paid. After the cotton gin, slavery grew. Slave states went from 6 in 1790 to 15 in 1860, and by 1860 about one in three Southerners was enslaved [5]. So the standard’s line that specialization “improves standards of living” was not true for them.

The West was already home

Homestead land was the homeland or treaty land of many Native American nations. As settlers came, Native people were pushed onto reservations. Reservation land shrank from 138 million acres in 1887 to 48 million in 1934 [10].

Most miners did not get rich

Very few gold miners got rich. The people who made the most money sold food, tools, and services to the miners [6].

Prices can jump

When the Civil War cut off cotton, the price went from 10 cents a pound in 1860 to $1.89 in 1863 to 1864, almost 19 times as much [7].

Free land was not always free

Many workers could not afford the tools, seed, and animals to start a farm. Of about 500 million acres the government gave out from 1862 to 1904, about 80 million went to homesteaders [2].

Real tools

Where to see it for real