Middle school · 6th grade · SS6E1
Three countries, three answers
Every country decides what to make, how to make it, and who gets it, and Mexico, Brazil, and Cuba decide in different ways.
The standard
What Georgia asks you to know
SS6E1: Analyze different economic systems. (Latin America)
- Compare how traditional, command, and market economies answer the economic questions of 1-what to produce, 2-how to produce, and 3-for whom to produce.
- Explain that countries have a mixed economic system located on a continuum between pure market and pure command.
- Compare and contrast the basic types of economic systems found in Mexico, Cuba, and Brazil.
Everything below covers all three, then keeps going into what the standard leaves out.
In real life
Who owns the oil company?
The gas in a bus or a delivery truck starts as oil pumped from the ground. Who owns the company that pumps it tells you a lot about a country’s economy.
Mexico. Pemex, Mexico’s oil company, is wholly owned by the Mexican government [1]. Yet Mexico’s constitution says the public, social, and private sectors all contribute to the economy [4]. That article was changed in October 2024, and the line about the three sectors stayed [1] [4].
Brazil. Petrobras is a mix. By law, Brazil’s federal government must hold a majority of its voting shares. Its other shares belong to private investors and trade on stock exchanges, including the New York Stock Exchange [2]. Brazil’s constitution names private property and free competition as principles of its economy [5].
Cuba. Cuba’s 2019 constitution sets up a socialist economy. Ownership “by all people” of the fundamental means of production is the main form of property, and the government plans the economy [3]. The means of production are what people use to make things: land, factories, and machines. Private ownership is allowed, with what the constitution calls a “complementary role” [3].
| Country | Workers in government jobs, 2025 | Heritage score, 2026 | Rank of 176 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mexico | 9.6% | 59.8 | 92 |
| Brazil | 12.5% | 52.4 | 134 |
| Cuba | not reported | 25.2 | 175 |
| United States | 13.4% | 72.8 | 22 |
The Heritage Foundation, a U.S. research group that favors free markets, scores 176 economies from 0 to 100 on 12 things, including property rights, taxes, government spending, and trade rules [6]. A higher score means Heritage judges the economy to be freer for private businesses and buyers. It is one group’s measure, and the labels it gives each score are its own. Mexico scores 34.6 points higher than Cuba. The government jobs column comes from the International Labour Organization, which has no figure for Cuba [7].
Try it
Put two countries on the line
Pick any two. The tool places them on Heritage’s 0 to 100 scale for 2026 [6] and shows the gap.
A score is not a grade for the people who live there. It is one group’s judgment of how much room the rules leave for private choices.
Three questions
Same questions, three kinds of answers
Every economy has to answer three questions. What should be produced? How should it be produced? For whom is it produced? An economic system is a country’s way of answering them.
Traditional
- What
- What families have always made
- How
- Methods passed down
- For whom
- Shared by custom
Command
- What
- What the government plans
- How
- Government decides
- For whom
- Government decides
Market
- What
- What buyers will pay for
- How
- The way that costs sellers least
- For whom
- Whoever can pay the price
You decide
Which system is making each choice? These are examples, not real cases.
- A family plants the same corn and beans their grandparents planted and shares the harvest with relatives.
- A government office tells farms how many tons of rice to grow this year.
- A sneaker store raises its price because one model keeps selling out.
- A bakery owner buys a machine to make tortillas faster and cheaper.
- A city government sets the fare for its buses.
- A fishing village splits the catch the way it always has.
Show the answers
1 and 6 are traditional: custom decides. 2 and 5 are command: the government decides. 3 and 4 are market: a business decides, based on what buyers want and what costs less. Number 5 happens in most market countries, which is the point of the next section.
The continuum
No country is pure
Picture a line. At one end is pure market: the government makes no economic choices. At the other end is pure command: the government makes all of them. No real country sits at either end. Every country is a mixed economy somewhere in between.
Mexico and Brazil lean market. About 9 in 10 workers in each country work outside government [7], and most businesses are private. Both governments still run giant oil companies [1] [2].
Cuba leans command. State ownership is the main form of property, and planning is written into the constitution [3]. Heritage’s 2026 report says prices in Cuba are subject to controls and private business is limited [6]. Private ownership still exists in the constitution, so Cuba is not pure command either [3].
How they compare
Alike: all three are mixed, and the governments of Mexico and Brazil both own big oil companies. Different: Mexico’s government owns all of Pemex, while private investors own part of Petrobras. In Mexico and Brazil, private ownership is the main form and government has a role. In Cuba, it is the other way around.
Beyond the standard
What the textbook version leaves out
An index is one group’s yardstick
Heritage’s score also counts courts, honest government, and taxes, not only who owns businesses [6]. A group that weighed things differently would rank countries differently.
Many government jobs is not command
A larger share of U.S. workers have government jobs, 13.4%, than in Mexico, 9.6% [7]. Teachers and firefighters are government workers in market economies too. What matters is who decides what gets made and what it costs.
Systems shift over time
Cuba’s current constitution was approved by a national vote on February 24, 2019 [3]. In 2021, a Cuban decree-law dated August 6 set rules for small and medium businesses. The 2024 law that replaced it lets them be privately owned, with up to 100 workers [9]. In Mexico, a change to the constitution turned Pemex from a “productive state-owned company” into a “state-owned public company” on November 1, 2024. A new law finished the change on March 19, 2025 [1]. Where a country sits on the line can move.
Comparing Cuba is hard
The World Bank’s newest figure for Cuba’s output per person is from 2020, while Mexico and Brazil have 2025 figures [8]. Older data makes side-by-side comparisons less certain.
Real tools
Where this happens for real
- World Bank: Mexico, Brazil, and Cuba: population, output, schooling, and more for each country.
- Heritage Index of Economic Freedom: scores, country pages, and the full data download.
- ILOSTAT: the International Labour Organization’s data on jobs and workers in each country.
Sources
Where every number comes from
All checked October 24, 2026. Government job shares and the score gaps were calculated from the figures shown.
- Petróleos Mexicanos, Annual Report on Form 20-F for 2025, filed with the SEC April 30, 2026: wholly owned by the Mexican government; changed from a productive state-owned company to a state-owned public company on November 1, 2024, under amendments to Articles 25, 27, and 28 of the constitution published October 31, 2024; the 2025 Pemex law took effect March 19, 2025.
- Petrobras, Annual Report on Form 20-F for 2025, filed with the SEC April 9, 2026: federal government required by law to hold a majority of voting shares; shares listed on B3 and the New York Stock Exchange.
- Constitution of Cuba, 2019, English translation, Constitute Project: Articles 18, 19, and 22; approved by referendum February 24, 2019.
- Constitución Política de los Estados Unidos Mexicanos, official text from Mexico’s Chamber of Deputies, last amended October 7, 2026: Article 25, “the public sector, the social sector, and the private sector” contribute to national economic development (translated). Article 25 was amended October 31, 2024. An older English translation is at the Constitute Project (through 2015).
- Constitution of Brazil, 1988, as amended through 2017, English translation by Keith S. Rosenn, Constitute Project: Article 170 on free enterprise, private property, and free competition.
- Heritage Foundation, 2026 Index of Economic Freedom, February 2026: scores and ranks for 176 economies, the 12 measures, and the Cuba country summary. Data compiled as of January 2026. A think-tank index, not official statistics.
- International Labour Organization, ILOSTAT, Employment by institutional sector, 2025: public sector workers as a share of all employed, from Mexico’s ENOE, Brazil’s PNAD Contínua, and the U.S. Current Population Survey.
- World Bank, World Development Indicators: GDP per capita, last updated October 8, 2026: latest year 2025 for Mexico and Brazil, 2020 for Cuba.
- Gaceta Oficial de la República de Cuba, GOC-2024-O78, August 19, 2024: Decreto-Ley 88, Sobre las micro, pequeñas y medianas empresas, copy held by FAO’s FAOLEX: replaces Decreto-Ley 46 of August 6, 2021; businesses may be state, private, or mixed; medium businesses have 36 to 100 workers.