Middle school · 6th grade · SS6E7
Who decides in Europe’s economies
Every country has to decide what to make, how to make it, and who gets it. The United Kingdom, Germany, and Russia answer in different ways.
The standard
What Georgia asks you to know
SS6E7: Analyze different economic systems. (Europe)
- Compare how traditional, command, and market economies answer the economic questions of 1-what to produce, 2-how to produce, and 3-for whom to produce.
- Explain that countries have a mixed economic system located on a continuum between pure market and pure command.
- Compare the basic types of economic systems found in the United Kingdom, Germany, and Russia.
Everything below covers all three, then keeps going into what the standard leaves out.
In real life
Who sets the price of heating a home?
Picture a family in London, one in Berlin, and one in Moscow. All three use gas to heat their homes. The question is the same in each city: who decides what the energy costs? The answer shows how each economy works.
| Country | Who sets the price of gas for homes | Freedom score, 2026 | Government spending, share of the economy |
|---|---|---|---|
| United Kingdom mixed | Each supplier sets its prices, but a government regulator sets the most it can charge per unit [2] | 70.4 | 44.3% |
| Germany mixed | Suppliers set prices. A government limit in 2023 ended on December 31, 2023 [4] | 71.7 | 48.7% |
| Russia mixed | The state sets prices for end users [5] | 50.3 | 35.9% |
In Britain, the regulator is Ofgem. From October 1 to December 31, 2026, its cap works out to £1,723 a year for gas and electricity together, for a typical home paying by direct debit [3]. The cap limits the price of each unit, not the whole bill. Use more energy, and the bill goes up [2].
In Russia, the biggest gas seller is Gazprom. The government and companies it controls own more than half of it [6].
Reading the table: the freedom score and spending share come from the Heritage Foundation, a U.S. research group that favors free markets [11]. It scores 176 countries from 0 to 100 on how much people and businesses decide for themselves [1]. It is one group’s measure, not a fact of nature. Spending is a three-year average for all levels of government. The system labels are this page’s.
Try it
Who decides? Sort six real choices
Pick a decision, then pick who makes it. The first one is filled in for you. The two marked “example” are made up to show the idea. The rest are real.
Real choices can mix more than one answer. Each explanation says why it leans the way it does.
The line
Three ways to answer three questions
Every economy has to answer three questions. What should be made? How should it be made? For whom, meaning who gets it? There are three pure ways to answer.
Traditional
In a traditional economy, custom decides. People make what their families always made, the way they always made it. Who gets what is set by family or by long-held rules.
Command
In a command economy, the government decides. Planners choose what factories make, how they make it, and who gets it. The government owns most businesses and sets most prices.
Market
In a market economy, buyers and sellers decide. A business makes what people will pay for. It picks the cheapest way to make it. People who pay the price get it. A price is what a buyer gives up to get something, and it rises when many people want something that is scarce.
Every real country is mixed
No country uses only one system. Each is a mixed economy that sits somewhere on a line, called a continuum, between pure command and pure market. Here is where the Heritage Foundation puts five countries in 2026 [1]. A higher score means people and businesses decide more for themselves.
North Korea, near the command end, ranks last of 176 [1]. No country reaches 100. The UK, Germany, and the U.S. sit close together on the market side. Russia sits near the middle.
Three countries
The UK, Germany, and Russia up close
United Kingdom: a market with a public health service
Heritage rates the UK “mostly free” in its own labels, 29th of 176, with a business freedom score far above the world average [1]. One big answer to “for whom” comes from the government. In England, NHS health care is free of charge, with limited exceptions set by Parliament. You get care based on how sick you are, not on what you can pay [8]. Energy is a mix: suppliers set prices under Ofgem’s cap [2].
Germany: a “social market economy”
Germany’s government calls its system a social market economy. The main idea has two halves: protect a free economy and fair competition, and support prosperity and social security [9]. Businesses decide what to make and charge. The law adds rules on top. Since January 1, 2026, no employer can pay less than €13.90 an hour [7]. Heritage ranks Germany 24th and labels it “mostly free” [1].
Russia: markets with a heavy state hand
Russia has private shops and businesses, but the state controls some of the largest companies. Government holdings in Gazprom are above 50% [6], and the state sets the price of gas for homes [5]. Heritage says the state’s influence on prices is extensive and that state interference holds back private business. It ranks Russia 145th and labels it “mostly unfree” [1].
You decide
Germany’s government spends 48.7% of the economy. Russia’s spends 35.9% [1]. So is Germany closer to command?
Show the answer
No. Spending is not the same as deciding. In Germany, businesses still choose what to make and what to charge [9]. In Russia, the state spends less, but it controls big companies like Gazprom and sets some prices directly [6] [5]. Command is about who decides, not how much the government spends.
Beyond the standard
What the textbook version skips
Russia is mixed, too
It is easy to file Russia under “command.” It is not a planned economy like North Korea. People run private businesses there, even though the state holds back their growth, in Heritage’s view. Heritage puts Russia at 50.3, near the middle of the line, not at the end [1].
Rules can come and go
Germany put a temporary limit on gas prices for homes and small businesses. It started in 2023 and ended on December 31, 2023 [4]. A country can slide a little along the line and back.
A cap is not a fixed bill
Ofgem’s cap limits the price of each unit of energy and the daily charge. It does not limit the total. A family that heats a big, drafty house still pays more [2].
An index is someone’s yardstick
Heritage scores government spending against a benchmark of zero, and says so in its method [1]. That choice pulls down countries that spend a lot, like Germany. The Fraser Institute, a research group in Canada, builds a different index [10]. Check how a ranking is made before you quote it.
Real tools
Where to look it up yourself
- Heritage Foundation, Index of Economic Freedom: a score and a short write-up for each country.
- World Bank country data: pick any country to see its income, population, and more.
- Ofgem, Energy price cap: how Britain’s cap works and what it is right now.
Sources
Where every number comes from
All checked October 24, 2026.
- Heritage Foundation, 2026 Index of Economic Freedom, February 2026: scores and ranks for the UK (70.4, 29th), Germany (71.7, 24th), Russia (50.3, 145th), the U.S. (72.8, 22nd), and North Korea (3.1, 176th); three-year government spending averages; Russia country page; method for government spending.
- Ofgem, “Energy price cap”: suppliers decide their prices; the cap is the most they can charge per unit and per day, and it does not limit the total bill.
- Ofgem, “Energy price cap unit rates and standing charges”: £1,723 a year for gas and electricity together, October 1 to December 31, 2026, typical direct debit customer.
- German Federal Government, “Gas- und Strompreisbremsen” (in German): the 2023 gas and electricity price limits, ended December 31, 2023.
- Gazprom, “Domestic market”: gas prices for end consumers in Russia are subject to state regulation.
- Gazprom, shareholder structure, as of December 31, 2024: the Russian Federation and state-controlled companies hold more than 50%.
- German Federal Ministry of Labour and Social Affairs, “Mindestlohn” (in German): €13.90 an hour since January 1, 2026.
- Department of Health and Social Care, The NHS Constitution for England, updated August 17, 2023: services free of charge with limited exceptions; access based on need, not ability to pay.
- deutschland.de, “Social market economy in Germany”, June 2018, quoting the Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs: protect a free economy and competition, and foster prosperity and social security.
- Fraser Institute, Economic Freedom of the World: a separate index from a Canadian research group.
- Heritage Foundation, “Mission”: promotes policies based on the principles of free enterprise.