Middle school · 7th grade · SS7E1
Three countries, three mixes
Every economy decides what to make, how to make it, and who gets it. Nigeria, South Africa, and Kenya each split those choices between markets and government in their own way.
The standard
What Georgia asks you to know
SS7E1: Analyze different economic systems. (Africa)
- Compare how traditional, command, and market economies answer the economic questions of 1-what to produce, 2-how to produce, and 3-for whom to produce.
- Explain that countries have a mixed economic system located on a continuum between pure market and pure command.
- Compare and contrast the economic systems in South Africa, Nigeria, and Kenya.
Everything below covers all three, then keeps going into what the standard leaves out.
In real life
Who sets the price of fuel?
Every country has to answer three questions. What gets made? How does it get made? Who gets it? A country’s economic system is its way of answering them. One quick test is to ask who sets the price of something almost every family buys. Here is petrol, the gasoline most cars run on, in October 2026.
| Country | Who sets the price | October 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| Kenya government | A government agency sets the highest price a station may charge, once a month [1] | KSh 226.96 a liter in Nairobi, about $6.61 a gallon |
| South Africa government | A government minister announces new prices each month [3] | 95 octane up R3.33 a liter, 93 octane up R3.12, on October 7 |
| Nigeria market | The law leaves prices to sellers in an open market, and the regulator says it does not fix pump prices [4] | No single national price |
| United States market | Each station sets its own price | $4.284 a gallon, national average, October 19 [5] |
Same fuel, different answers. A family in Nairobi paid about $6.61 a gallon at the government’s top price, compared with $4.284 in the United States. One government price does not make a whole country a command economy, though.
How the dollar figure was figured: KSh 226.96 a liter divided by 129.89 shillings per dollar, the Central Bank of Kenya rate posted October 23, 2026 [2], times 3.785 liters in a gallon.
Three ways to answer the three questions
Traditional economy: custom decides. People make what their parents and grandparents made, the way they made it, and share it by family rules.
Command economy: the government decides. Planners choose what gets made, which methods to use, and who receives it.
Market economy: buyers and sellers decide. Businesses make what people will pay for, pick the cheapest way to make it, and sell to whoever pays the price.
A mixed economy blends these. Every real country is a mix.
Try it
Who decides? Sort six real choices
Pick who answers each one. The first is sorted for you: in Kenya, a government agency sets the highest legal price for petrol [1]. Number 4 is an example, not a real case.
The continuum
Every country sits somewhere on a line
Picture a line. At one end is pure command, where the government decides everything. At the other end is pure market, where buyers and sellers decide everything. No real country sits at either end. A line like this, with no clear breaks along it, is called a continuum.
One way to place countries on it is an index, a score built from many measures. The Heritage Foundation, a U.S. research group that favors free markets, scores 176 countries from 0 to 100 on how much people and businesses decide for themselves. Its 2026 scores use data from mid-2024 to mid-2025 [6]. By Heritage’s measure, higher means closer to the market end.
All three African countries land within 3.8 points of each other, in the group Heritage calls “mostly unfree” [6]. This is one group’s measure. Heritage chooses what to count and how much each part matters, so treat the score as one group’s view, not a fact of nature.
Compare and contrast
Nigeria, South Africa, and Kenya
Nigeria
Oil is most of what Nigeria sells to other countries. Fuels made up 85.9% of its goods exports in 2025 [10]. The national oil company began as a government corporation in 1977. Since 2021 it has been a company, NNPC Ltd., with officials from two government ministries on its board [8]. By 2024, the IMF reported that Nigeria’s new government had reformed fuel subsidies, payments that had held the pump price down [11]. Government spending is the smallest of the three, 11.1% of the economy on average [6].
South Africa
South Africa’s government owns all of Eskom, the main power company, which runs 30 power stations [7]. It also sets the price of petrol each month [3]. Its government spends the most of the three, 32.4% of the economy on average. Heritage says a fairly open trade system has helped a growing number of private businesses get started [6].
Kenya
Kenya’s government sets the top price for fuel each month [1]. In June 2026 it sold 15% of Safaricom, a phone company, to Vodacom, a South African company, for KSh 204 billion. Vodacom now owns 55% [9]. Government spending averages 23.0% of the economy [6]. Farming is a big part of daily work: 45.8% of Kenyan workers were in agriculture in 2025 [10].
Which of the three leans furthest toward government?
Show one way to answer
It depends on what you measure. By spending, South Africa leans furthest, at 32.4%. By Heritage’s overall score, Nigeria is lowest, 54.8, but only 3.8 points below South Africa [6]. Nigeria’s government spends the least, yet its biggest export runs through a national oil company. Kenya and South Africa set fuel prices, and Nigeria does not.
A strong answer names its evidence. There is no single correct ranking, which is why all three are called mixed economies.
Beyond the standard
What the standard leaves out
The line leaves out tradition
Element (b) puts every country on a line from command to market. Tradition, the third system in element (a), has no spot on that line. That is a limit of the model. It does not mean custom stopped mattering.
Countries move along the line
Since 1995, Nigeria’s Heritage score has risen 7.5 points and Kenya’s 1.0. South Africa’s has fallen 2.1 [6]. Where a country sits can change.
Selling a government company
When a government sells part of a company it owns, that is called privatization. Kenya’s sale of 15% of Safaricom for KSh 204 billion [9], about $1.57 billion, moved part of that company from public to private hands.
Holding a price down has a cost
A subsidy is government money that covers part of a price. Someone still pays, through taxes or borrowing. The IMF called Nigeria’s energy subsidies “costly and regressive,” meaning they cost a lot and helped better-off families most [11].
Real tools
Look it up yourself
- IMF country pages: Nigeria, South Africa, and Kenya. Growth and inflation forecasts, plus the IMF’s reports on each economy.
- World Bank Open Data: Nigeria, South Africa, and Kenya. Charts of income, population, and trade over time.
- Heritage Foundation, Index of Economic Freedom: search any country to see its score and what pulls it up or down.
- Kenya EPRA pump prices: this month’s government-set fuel prices for every Kenyan town.
Sources
Where every number comes from
All checked October 24, 2026. The dollar price of fuel in Kenya and the dollar value of the Safaricom sale were calculated from the rates shown.
- Energy and Petroleum Regulatory Authority (Kenya), Pump Prices, October 15 to November 14, 2026: Nairobi super petrol, KSh 226.96 a liter, the maximum retail price.
- Central Bank of Kenya, Daily KES Exchange Rates, posted October 23, 2026: 129.89 shillings per U.S. dollar.
- South African Government, fuel price adjustment from October 7, 2026, Minister of Mineral and Petroleum Resources, October 5, 2026: prices adjusted monthly; 95 octane petrol up 333 cents a liter, 93 octane up 312 cents.
- Gazette Nigeria, report on the Nigerian Midstream and Downstream Petroleum Regulatory Authority, September 19, 2026: the regulator “does not fix pump prices,” citing Section 205 of the Petroleum Industry Act 2021 (free market pricing). A news report; no official copy of the statement was reachable.
- U.S. Energy Information Administration, Gasoline and Diesel Fuel Update, released October 20, 2026: U.S. regular gasoline, $4.284 a gallon, week of October 19, 2026.
- Heritage Foundation, 2026 Index of Economic Freedom, February 2026: scores and ranks (U.S. 72.8, 22nd; South Africa 58.6, 100th; Kenya 55.5, 116th; Nigeria 54.8, 119th; 176 countries graded), three-year government spending averages, change since 1995, the 12 measures, and country notes.
- Eskom, Company information: “entirely owned by the South African government,” 30 power stations.
- NNPC Ltd., company history and board: corporation formed April 1, 1977; incorporated as NNPC Ltd. under the Petroleum Industry Act in 2021; board members representing the Ministry of Finance and the Ministry of Petroleum Resources.
- Vodafone Group, “Vodafone completes Safaricom transaction,” regulatory announcement, June 30, 2026: Vodacom bought 15% of Safaricom from the Government of Kenya for KSh 204 billion and now holds 55%.
- World Bank, World Development Indicators, updated October 8, 2026: fuel exports, % of merchandise exports, Nigeria 2025 (TX.VAL.FUEL.ZS.UN); employment in agriculture, Kenya 2025, modeled ILO estimate (SL.AGR.EMPL.ZS).
- International Monetary Fund, Press Release No. 24/144, May 8, 2024: Nigeria “reformed the fuel price subsidies”; “phasing out costly and regressive energy subsidies.”
- Fraser Institute, Economic Freedom of the World: a second, separate economic freedom index.