Middle school · 7th grade · SS7E4
Who decides in the Middle East
Every country decides what to make, how to make it, and who gets it. Israel, Saudi Arabia, and Turkey split those decisions between markets and government in different amounts.
The standard
What Georgia asks you to know
SS7E4: Analyze different economic systems. (Southwest Asia / Middle East)
- Compare how traditional, command, and market economies answer the economic questions of 1-what to produce, 2-how to produce, and 3-for whom to produce.
- Explain that countries have a mixed economic system located on a continuum between pure market and pure command.
- Compare and contrast the economic systems in Israel, Saudi Arabia, and Turkey.
Everything below covers all three, then keeps going into what the standard leaves out.
In real life
Who owns the oil company?
Saudi Arabia is the biggest oil producer in OPEC, a group of oil-selling countries [8]. Oil and other fuels made up 78.7% of everything Saudi Arabia sold to other countries in 2025 [9]. Almost all of that oil comes from one company, Saudi Aramco. Here is who owned Aramco on December 31, 2025 [1]:
The government and its own fund own about 97.5% of the company. The government also decides the most crude oil the country may pump, and how much pumping power Aramco must keep ready. That is now set at 12.0 million barrels a day [1]. Inside the country, Aramco must sell crude oil and some fuels at prices the government sets [1].
So who gets the money? In 2025 Aramco paid the Saudi government 598.1 billion riyals in taxes, royalties (a fee for using the oil), and dividends (an owner’s share of the profit) [1]. That is about $159.5 billion, or about $4,300 for every person living in Saudi Arabia [3]. The government decides how to spend it.
Now compare Israel. In 2025, people there started about 775 new tech companies [4]. Each one chose what to build and what to charge, and buyers chose whether to pay. Turkey sits in between. The Heritage Foundation, a U.S. research group that favors free markets, describes heavy government involvement alongside a private sector that is growing fast [2].
How the numbers were figured: 81.48% plus 16.00% is 97.48%. The rest is 2.48% held by the public and 0.04% held by Aramco itself. Riyals were changed to dollars at the fixed rate of 3.75 riyals per dollar, then divided by Saudi Arabia’s 2025 population of about 37.0 million.
Try it
Who makes the call? Sort six decisions
Pick who makes each decision. Two are sorted for you: the Saudi government sets the country’s top oil output [1], and the founders of a new Israeli tech company decide what it sells [4]. The two family examples are illustrations, not real cases.
Real decisions can mix more than one answer. Each explanation says why it leans the way it does.
Three questions
What, how, and for whom
Every economy has to answer three questions. What gets made? How does it get made? For whom, meaning who gets it? An economic system is a country’s way of answering them.
Traditional
Custom answers. People make what their families have always made, the way they always made it, and share it by long-held rules. A herding family that raises goats because their parents did is the classic example.
Command
The government answers. Planners decide what gets made, set the prices, and decide who gets what. Saudi oil works partly this way: the government owns most of the company, sets the output limit, and sets fuel prices at home [1].
Market
Buyers and sellers answer. Businesses make what people will pay for. When something is scarce, its price rises. When there is too much, its price falls. An app company that builds something no one buys runs out of money.
Every real country is mixed
No country uses only one system. Picture a line with pure command at one end and pure market at the other. Every real economy sits somewhere in between. That is a mixed economy.
One way to place countries on that line is the Index of Economic Freedom from the Heritage Foundation, a U.S. research group that favors free markets, based in Washington, D.C. It scores 176 countries from 0 to 100 on things like property rights, taxes, government spending, business rules, and trade. In Heritage’s scoring, a higher number means more decisions are left to people and businesses [2]. It is one group’s measure, built on its own choices about what to count.
No country scores 0 or 100 [2]. Even the top country keeps some government, and even the last one has some trading.
Three countries
Israel, Saudi Arabia, and Turkey side by side
GDP per person is the value of everything a country makes in a year, divided by the number of people. Government spending and taxes are shown as a share of GDP, so a bigger number means the government handles a bigger slice of the economy.
| Country | Heritage score, 2026 | Rank of 176 | Government spending | Taxes | GDP per person, 2025 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Israel | 68.4 | 41 | 40.0% | 30.9% | $60,337 |
| Saudi Arabia | 65.4 | 59 | 27.7% | 8.2% | $34,537 |
| Turkey | 55.0 | 117 | 30.6% | 24.0% | $18,599 |
Reading the table: scores, ranks, spending, and taxes come from Heritage’s 2026 Index, mostly on 2025 data [2]. Spending is a three-year average. GDP per person is in U.S. dollars from the World Bank [3].
Israel: mostly private, with a big public budget
Most businesses are privately owned and compete to sell. Tech companies alone made 18.3% of everything Israel produced in 2025 [4]. Heritage says Israel’s rules encourage people to start businesses [2]. The government still spends the biggest share of the three, 40.0% of GDP.
Saudi Arabia: a state oil giant, low taxes
The state owns most of the biggest company and sets oil output and fuel prices at home [1]. Heritage says government subsidies (payments that lower prices) and state-owned companies influence prices. It also says starting a business now takes less time [2]. Taxes are only 8.2% of GDP.
Turkey: private business and a strong state
Heritage describes heavy government involvement, a private sector that is growing fast, and paperwork that still slows new businesses [2]. The government sets a national minimum wage each year [5]. Prices rose fast: inflation, the rate at which prices go up, was 34.9% in 2025 [7].
Here is a puzzle. Saudi Arabia scores higher than Turkey, yet the Saudi government owns most of the biggest company. How can both be true?
Show the answer
The score adds up twelve different things. Saudi Arabia scores 99.2 out of 100 for low taxes and 81.2 for steady prices. Turkey scores 72.0 and 36.5 on those same two parts [2]. Those parts lift the Saudi total, even though the state owns the oil company. One number never tells the whole story, so look at what is inside it.
Beyond the standard
What the standard leaves out
A state company you can buy a piece of
On December 11, 2019, the Saudi government sold 1.73% of Aramco on the Saudi stock exchange. It sold another 0.7% in June 2024. Buyers and sellers now trade those shares every day, while the state keeps the rest [1].
Low taxes, paid for by oil
Saudi taxes equal 8.2% of GDP, compared with 30.9% in Israel [2]. Aramco’s payments to the government came to about $4,300 per person in 2025 [1]. When oil prices fall, that money falls too.
Who gets to work is changing
In Saudi Arabia, the share of women 15 and older who work or are looking for work rose from 19.9% in 2017 to 33.6% in 2025, by International Labour Organization estimates [6]. More workers changes how a country answers “how to produce.”
Fast-rising prices
Turkey’s prices rose 58.5% in 2024 and 34.9% in 2025 [7]. At 34.9%, a snack that cost 100 lira would cost about 135 lira a year later. Markets still set most prices, but saving gets harder when money loses value that fast.
Real tools
Where to look it up yourself
- World Bank: Saudi Arabia, Israel, and Türkiye: GDP, population, and hundreds of other numbers for each country.
- Heritage Foundation, Index of Economic Freedom: the scores and a short write-up for each country.
- Aramco: reports and presentations: the company’s own yearly report, including who owns it.
Sources
Where every number comes from
All checked October 24, 2026. The 97.5% ownership share, the dollar value of Aramco’s payments, and the per-person figure were calculated from the sources shown.
- Saudi Aramco, Annual Report 2025, March 2026: shareholding at December 31, 2025 (government 81.48%, investment fund and its companies 16.00%, public 2.48%); government sets the country’s maximum crude output and Aramco’s maximum sustainable capacity, now 12.0 million barrels a day; regulated prices at home; 2025 payments to the government of SAR 598.1 billion; 2019 and 2024 share sales.
- Heritage Foundation, 2026 Index of Economic Freedom, February 2026: scores, ranks of 176, government spending, tax burden, component scores, and country descriptions for Israel, Saudi Arabia, Türkiye, the United States, Singapore, and North Korea.
- World Bank, GDP per capita (current US$) and population, updated October 8, 2026: 2025 values for Israel, Saudi Arabia, and Türkiye.
- Israel Innovation Authority, The State of High Tech 2026, May 2026: about 775 new tech companies in 2025; tech at 18.3% of GDP.
- Moroğlu Arseven, on the Minimum Wage Determination Commission’s 2026 decision: published in Türkiye’s Official Gazette, No. 33119, December 26, 2025, effective January 1, 2026.
- World Bank, Labor force participation rate, female (modeled ILO estimate), updated October 8, 2026: Saudi Arabia, 2017 and 2025.
- World Bank, Inflation, consumer prices (annual %), updated October 8, 2026: Türkiye, 2024 and 2025.
- U.S. Energy Information Administration, “Supply: OPEC”: Saudi Arabia is OPEC’s largest producer and exporter.
- World Bank, Fuel exports (% of merchandise exports), updated October 8, 2026: Saudi Arabia, 2025.